Cooling Towers using Liquid/Gas Phase Change

it doesn't have to be about Mars!
Post Reply
tahanson43206
Site Admin
Posts: 493
Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2024 11:24 pm
Location: Earth
Contact:

Re: Cooling Towers using Liquid/Gas Phase Change

Post by tahanson43206 »

For this post, I asked Google to find videos about cooling towers used for nuclear power plants.

The collection below appears to be reasonably well matched to the request. Videos about maintenance are included, so there appears to be information about how scale is removed. There would be a ** lot ** of scale if sea water is used for cooling.

Query: find video about cooling towers for nuclear power plants operation maintenance

Working of Cooling Tower - Nuclear Power Plant

YouTube · iLearn Education
240.3K+ views · 7 years ago

3:57
For any efficient power plant to function at its optimum level, cooling towers form an essential unit. They are used to transfer heat and ...

How does a cooling tower work?

YouTube · PSEG Nuclear
150.1K+ views · 5 years ago

2:00
Heated water from the condenser flows to the cooling tower and is distributed through pipes in the lower portion approximately 40 feet high.
I Went INSIDE a Nuclear Cooling Tower

YouTube · Kyle Hill
365.7K+ views · 8 months ago

13:34
I got the extremely rare opportunity to actually go inside one of these concrete colossi while touring a power plant in Slovakia.
Understanding Cooling Towers in Nuclear Power Plants

TikTok · Armchair Engineer
791.2K+ views · 3 years ago

0:59
Learn how cooling towers function in nuclear power plants and why they require a significant amount of water to operate.
The Genius Engineering of Nuclear Cooling Towers

RealClearScience · Kyle Hill
https://www.realclearscience.com · Aug 9, 2025

13:34
Join me in Slovakia as we explain the genius engineering of the most iconic structure in the nuclear industry. Related Topics: nuclear energy.
Didcot B Power Station Cooling Tower Repair

SPX Cooling Technologies · SPX Cooling Tech, LLC
https://spxcooling.com · Sep 6, 2023

2:37
Follow our Time Lapse video as SPX repairs Didcot B Power Station's cooling tower cells to their original design following an unfortunate fire.
What Are Cooling Towers?

YouTube · The Heritage Foundation
195.3K+ views · 13 years ago

3:45
Is nuclear energy safe? Can it really meet all of our energy needs? Powering America answers these questions and more by pulling back the ...

Video: Improving Cooling Tower System Efficiency with ...

Better Buildings Solution Center · Better Buildings
https://betterbuildingssolutioncenter.energy.gov · Feb 14, 2020

40:48
Maintaining cooling towers typically entails chemical treatments and regular blow-downs to control scale, corrosion, fouling, and biological ...

AI in Nuclear Power Plant - Nuclear Plant Design

AVEVA
https://engage.aveva.com
Learn how data driven strategies are reshaping the nuclear power plant of the future.
‎Access the Demo Hub · ‎Nuclear Power Simulation · ‎View the Infographic · ‎5 Ways to Spark Growth
10K+ visits in past month

S1E8 – Nuclear Power Plants Essentials – Cooling Tower

Vimeo
https://vimeo.com › Engineering All Sorts › Videos
Dec 19, 2019 — In this video we'll finally find out what those big concrete towers are used for in a nuclear power plant! This is where the water used to ...Read more
Working of Cooling Tower- Nuclear Power Plant

YouTube · National Council of Science Museums (NCSM)
2.7K+ views · 3 years ago

0:57
Nuclear Power Plants have cooling towers, learn how it works and its functions Understand Science through the exhibit #amritmahotsav ...

People also search for
How do power Station cooling towers work
Why don t all nuclear power plants have cooling towers
Inside Nuclear power plant cooling tower
How do large Cooling Towers work
Nuclear cooling tower diagram
What are the big towers at nuclear power plant
Practical engineering cooling towers
Natural draft cooling towers
It seems possible (perhaps even likely) that there are records of the quantity of water evaporated in natural draft cooling towers. That should match the quantity of "new" water needed to maintain the flow.

There might even be a correlation with the amount of power produced by the associated plants.

The challenge facing anyone considering use of sea water for cooling is whether there is a net benefit. Clearly fresh water supply allows nuclear plants to function at a profit. The amount of profit will decrease as power is consumed dealing with the minerals carried in sea water.

(th)
tahanson43206
Site Admin
Posts: 493
Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2024 11:24 pm
Location: Earth
Contact:

Re: Cooling Towers using Liquid/Gas Phase Change

Post by tahanson43206 »

For this post, I asked Google to find online resources to explain cooling tower design and operation.

The purpose of the inquiry is to evaluate the feasibility of using sea water as a supply source for power plant cooling.

A concern is removal of salt and other minerals at the same rate as they are supplied, while fresh water is evaporated and carried away in air.

Additional concerns arise due to corrosive effects of salt water.

Note: the collection below seems to be about cooling systems smaller than towers used for power plants. Examples might include industrial scale air conditioning systems for large buildings.

How Cooling Towers Work
YouTube · The Engineering Mindset
467.2K+ views · 10 years ago
13:00

In this video we look at how a cooling tower works. We take an overview of each main component with real world examples, ...
10 key moments in this video

AI Overview
+7
Cooling towers work by using evaporation to remove heat from industrial processes or HVAC systems, transferring it into the atmosphere. Hot water is sprayed over a fill material to increase surface area, where it meets upward-flowing air. This evaporates a portion of the water, cooling the remainder before it recirculates.

Here are top videos explaining the working principle of cooling towers:

The Engineering Mindset (Best Overall Visualization): How Cooling Towers Work - Uses clear animations to show the entire loop between the chiller and the tower, including the fan, fill, and spray nozzles.

Engineering Animation (Detailed 3D): How Cooling Tower Works - Explains components like the basin, drift eliminator, and fill material in a simulated environment.

Industrial Breakdown (Fast & Simple): Cooling Tower Working Principle - Explains the difference between counterflow and crossflow designs.

Key Components Shown in Videos:

Fill Material: Increases contact area between air and water.
Spray Nozzles: Distributes hot water evenly.
Fan: Draws/forces air through the tower. << a large tower uses convection = cold bottom / hot exit
Basin: Collects the cooled water for reuse.

How the Process Works:

Hot Water Entry: Warm water from machines/HVAC fills the tower.
Air Interaction: A fan moves air across the water spray.
Evaporation: A small amount of water evaporates, removing heat.
Cooling & Recirculation: The cold water is collected at the bottom and sent back to the system.
Because fresh water is removed during the evaporation process, brine is concentrated.

That brine must be removed in proportion to the fresh water evaporated.

(th)
tahanson43206
Site Admin
Posts: 493
Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2024 11:24 pm
Location: Earth
Contact:

Re: Cooling Towers using Liquid/Gas Phase Change

Post by tahanson43206 »

This post includes a BBCode summary of a discussion with Gemini about the use of evaporation cooling towers with sea water as input.
The Great Inland Sea-Exchange: Power, Water, and Mineral Abundance

A technical evaluation of utilizing seawater for large-scale evaporative cooling in arid environments.

[hr]

1. The Core Physics: The Tower as a Distillation Engine
At the scale of a project like the Hoover Dam, a nuclear or fossil fuel plant isn't just generating electricity; it is a thermal engine.
  • Phase Change: Cooling towers work by Latent Heat of Vaporization. When $H_{2}O$ evaporates, it absorbs $2,260\text{ kJ/kg}$ of energy.
  • Natural Separation: Evaporation is a natural filter. Only pure water molecules enter the atmosphere. Everything else—salts, minerals, and isotopes—stays behind in the basin.
  • Atmospheric Delivery: By launching this vapor in a desert context, we are essentially "seeding" the downwind air mass, creating a localized hydrological cycle.
The Abundance Insight: We are not "losing" water to the air; we are "delivering" fresh water to the wind, while concentrating valuable minerals for harvest in the basin.
2. Engineering the Salt Challenge
Traditional "scarcity" engineering fears salt due to corrosion and fouling. An "abundance" approach solves this through advanced material science:
  • The Titanium Barrier: By using an indirect loop with Titanium Plate-and-Frame Heat Exchangers, we isolate the plant’s sensitive turbines from the seawater.
  • Active Cleaning: With abundant energy, we can utilize automated mechanical scrubbing and ultrasonic anti-fouling systems to keep the "Sea Loop" operating at peak efficiency.
  • Drift Control: To prevent "salt rain" near the plant, Electrostatic Precipitators can be used at the tower's mouth to capture liquid salt droplets while allowing pure gas vapor to escape.
3. The Mineral Refinery (The Basin Mine)
Instead of treating "blowdown" water as waste, the concentrated brine becomes a high-value chemical feedstock.
3. The Mineral Refinery (The Basin Mine)
Instead of treating "blowdown" water as waste, the concentrated brine becomes a high-value chemical feedstock. Each mineral represents a distinct revenue stream:
  • Lithium
    • Potential Use: High-density battery storage for grid stability.
    • Recovery Method: Selective Ion Exchange / Adsorption.
  • Magnesium
    • Potential Use: Structural lightweight alloys for aerospace and automotive.
    • Recovery Method: Precipitation as Magnesium Hydroxide.
  • Sodium Chloride
    • Potential Use: Fundamental industrial chemical and de-icing.
    • Recovery Method: Fractional Crystallization.
  • Uranium
    • Potential Use: Closing the fuel cycle for on-site reactors.
    • Recovery Method: Amidoxime-functionalized fiber extraction.
4. Conclusion: A New Hydrological Paradigm
Just as the Hoover Dam redirected the Colorado River to create an empire in the West, this "Seawater-to-Vapor" model uses nuclear energy to tap into the ocean. It solves the cooling needs of the plant while simultaneously providing:
  1. Atmospheric Fresh Water for downwind regions.
  2. Strategic Mineral Independence through brine mining.
  3. Massive Carbon-Free Power for the surrounding infrastructure.
The challenges are purely a matter of engineering and capital—the physics of abundance suggests the resources are already in our hands.
(th)
tahanson43206
Site Admin
Posts: 493
Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2024 11:24 pm
Location: Earth
Contact:

Re: Cooling Towers using Liquid/Gas Phase Change

Post by tahanson43206 »

This post is reserved for an index to posts that may be contributed by NewMars members.

The primary cooling method offered for the NASA 10 Kilowatt reactor for Mars is radiation.

Evaporative cooling might have potential to support larger reactors, but how it would work remains as an exercise for NewMars members.

(th)
tahanson43206
Site Admin
Posts: 493
Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2024 11:24 pm
Location: Earth
Contact:

Cooling Towers using Liquid/Gas Phase Change

Post by tahanson43206 »

This topic is about cooling towers used by thermal energy power plants.

Our human experience through 2025 has been exclusively with evaporative cooling systems on Earth.

However, it seems possible (to me at least) such towers might work on Mars as well, with a few adjustments.

This topic opens with a request of Gemini to ** think ** about water cooling towers on Earth:

Conversation with Gemini
You said
Physics of Cooling Tower operation - Hello again! Thank you for your help with many previous requests. This one **should** be on the easier side for you, but we'll see. In conversation with another human about nuclear power plants, I suddenly realized I don't know how water cooling towers work, and if that is the reason so many such plants require great amounts of cooling water. Please evaluate the operation of water based cooling systems for nuclear plants. The principles may well apply to fossil fuel power plants as well.

Gemini said
It is a pleasure to dive back into the physics of infrastructure with you. It is a common misconception that the massive concrete "chimneys" (hyperboloid towers) at power plants are releasing smoke or harmful pollutants; in reality, they are essentially massive heat exchangers releasing nothing but pure water vapor.

Whether a plant uses nuclear or fossil fuels, the underlying thermodynamic cycle—usually the Rankine cycle—is almost identical. Here is how that heat is managed.

1. The Core Principle: Phase Change & Evaporation
The primary reason power plants require vast amounts of water is not just to "soak up" heat, but to use Latent Heat of Vaporization.

When water turns from a liquid to a gas, it absorbs a significant amount of energy (2,260 kJ/kg) without increasing in temperature. Cooling towers exploit this by bringing hot water into contact with moving air. A small portion of the water evaporates, and in doing so, it strips a massive amount of heat from the remaining liquid water.

2. How the Tower Functions
Most large-scale towers use Natural Draft cooling. The "hourglass" shape isn't just for aesthetics; it is a functional aerodynamic design.

The Heat Exchange: Hot water from the plant’s condenser is sprayed onto a "fill" (layers of PVC or wood slats) inside the tower. This breaks the water into tiny droplets to maximize the surface area.

The Chimney Effect: Because hot air is less dense than cold air, the warmed air inside the tower naturally rises. The narrow "waist" of the hyperboloid shape creates a pressure differential that accelerates this airflow, pulling cool air in through the bottom of the tower without the need for massive electric fans.

The Return Loop: The cooled water (which has lost its heat to the air and evaporation) collects in a basin at the bottom and is pumped back into the plant to start the cycle again.

3. Why Nuclear Plants Need So Much Water
Nuclear plants do indeed have a high "water footprint" compared to some fossil fuel counterparts, primarily due to Thermal Efficiency.

Lower Operating Temperatures
Unlike a modern natural gas plant, which can operate at extremely high temperatures, nuclear reactors typically operate at lower steam temperatures for safety and material integrity reasons. According to the Second Law of Thermodynamics, a lower temperature difference between the heat source and the cooling sink results in lower thermal efficiency.

As a result, a nuclear plant must reject more "waste heat" for every megawatt of electricity produced. To reject more heat, you need more water to facilitate that evaporation.

The Three Isolated Loops
It is important to note that the water you see evaporating from the tower is not the same water that touches the nuclear fuel. Nuclear plants use multiple loops to ensure containment:

Primary Loop: Circulates through the reactor core (Radioactive).

Secondary Loop: The steam that drives the turbines (Non-radioactive).

Tertiary (Cooling) Loop: Water that goes to the cooling tower or a nearby river (Non-radioactive).

4. Environmental Comparison
The physics of the cooling tower is identical for a coal-fired plant. However, because coal plants often run at higher steam pressures and temperatures, they are slightly more efficient and may require roughly 15% to 25% less cooling water per megawatt-hour than a standard Light Water Reactor (LWR).

A Note on "Once-Through" Cooling: Some plants don't use towers at all. They pull water directly from a river or ocean, pass it through the heat exchanger, and return it slightly warmer. This is even more water-intensive in terms of "
Gemini ran out of steam while attempting to compute the "A Note" section of the response.

(th)
Post Reply